Established, since 1997, leading UK based training provider.

How to Give Staff Appraisals

How to give staff appraisals

How to give staff appraisals

Why appraisals are important

Appraisals are the time when you are asked to give feedback to others.

Feedback is a subset of the Continuous improvement cycle.

  1. Set the goal
  2. Write the plan
  3. Take the actions
  4. Give feedback on the actions
  5. Change and adapt according to the feedback

The value of accurate feedback

Feedback is a specialised form of information that:

  1. Tells you how you are doing up to now, and
  2. Informs you of your next actions needed to achieve your goals

Feedback can be in three forms:

  1. You have taken action and find that you have made good progress.
  2. You have taken action and find that you have NOT made good progress.
  3. You have taken action and find that you have gone backwards (got worse: regressed).

Friend and colleague

There is a need to overcome your natural reluctance to critique a friend.

Many people like their colleagues and the thought of critiquing a friends performance to too much for some to bear.

So they FAIL to give the proper feedback.

This failure is to the detriment of:

  1. The friend
  2. The organisation
  3. The customer
  4. Yourself

Be prepared to give honest and objective feedback to a friend.

Distinguish between

1. Insult and feedback

Insults are defined as "vague, subjective, emotionalised and NOT containing a specific corrective action."

Example "You are a clown".

Feedback is defined as the opposite: "Specific, objective, NON emotionalised and containing a specific corrective action".

Example: "You are unshaven. In your role: You need to come to work well groomed".

2. Meaningless praise and feedback

Praise should also be specific, and honest.

Example: "That cover design was imaginative and eye catching. You are very good at this!"

NOT vague and empty "You're The CHAMP!"

Proper feedback has the following four characteristics:

1. Objective
Feedback should be objective:

That means:

  • Evidence based: Linked to specific named instances.
  • Accurate: Corresponding to the facts.

2. Brief
Feedback should be brief.
NOT unduly extended beyond necessity, with too many words, that could more easily have been said with a phase that was much shorter than this one!

3. Developmental

Feedback should provide solutions to any problematic errors.

Every weakness should be accompanied by an action plan to correct it.

4. Fair

  • Feedback illuminates the good
  • Feedback that identifies the NOT so good
  • Feedback that examines the BAD
  • Feedback that corrects


Appraisals are the time when you are asked to give feedback to others.
Feedback is a specialised form of information about the next actions needed to achieve your goals.
Sometimes you will need to critique a friend.

Distinguish between: Insult and feedback.

Distinguish between: Meaningless praise and feedback.
Develop your ability to be objective, brief and fair.
Ensure that you always come up with workable and agreed action plans.

Visit the Corporate Coach Group website for more information about our Management Training Courses

Leadership Training - The Effective Leader Manager Leadership and Management Training Course Logo

Leadership Training - The Effective Leader Manager

As the team leader or manager, you know that, on the technical level, you are very good. In your role as an effective and inspirational leader-manager, you recognise that there may be some gaps. Now you are searching for a method to help you to improve your skills as a team-leader and manager - click here to find out more!

Your Comments

Blog Email Subscription

Do you want to receive an email whenever we post a new blog?
The blogs contain article 5-10 minutes long - ideal for reading during your coffee break!
If you wish to sign up for this, please click here.

Further Reading in Leadership and Management

  • Emotional Management
    Emotional Management We all need to manage how we feel. We want to feel stronger and more confident. So, we need to learn the art of emotional management. Emotional Management is the art of controlling the focus of your mind and the physical state of your body, so as to create...
    Read Article >
  • ​Leadership and management development Part 1 of 6
    Leadership and management require that you set goals This six part essay covers the six major themes of leadership and management development. The six leadership and management development themes are as follows: Your leadership and management development programme needs to be centered on the six essential leadership management skills, namely the...
    Read Article >
  • Training to Help Managers
    Your managers may need help to fulfil their role, because they were not originally hired on the strength of their management skills, but for their technical skills and knowledge.
    Read Article >
  • Manage Yourself
    Manage Yourself It is said that, "The greatest victory is the victory over your own self". Have you ever wondered what it would be like to achieve complete mastery over your own self; you could live a life with no unnecessary worries, with no lingering self doubts, with no anger over...
    Read Article >
  • 20 Key Elements for Leadership Skills
    20 Key Elements for Leadership Skills Goals and self-confidence. All leaders are leaders because they share leadership qualities. If you have not developed leadership qualities then you cannot, by definition, become a leader. On the other hand, if you do develop your leadership qualities, then, to that degree, you qualify as...
    Read Article >