Established, since 1997, leading UK based training provider.

Onus of Proof Principle

Onus of Proof Principle

There is a principle of logic that says that the onus of proof is on the prosecution. The onus of proof is not on the accused.

The accused does not need to prove his/her innocence. The person who is making (or implying) an accusation, is the one who must prove their case.

Paula Radcliffe is suffering from implied allegations of misdeeds. Paula is making a tactical error, in that she is trying to prove her innocence. This is an error, both tactically and logically.

Logically it is an error, because you cannot prove a negative. Since, if nothing happened, then it leaves no clues. Only if something happened does it leave clues. You cannot prove that you didn't do something wrong.

For example, if I said to you, "I accuse you of being a shoplifter who has never been caught. Prove that you are not."

Then you would not be able to prove that you have not ever been a shoplifter. I could say that the absence of evidence of you shoplifting, merely goes to show how skilful you are at avoiding detection.

It is impossible to prove innocence. That is why, in our law courts, you don't have to prove yourself innocent. The prosecution has to prove you guilty, beyond all reasonable doubt.

In the press and on the TV, they break this rule and make assertions, which tantamount to allegations, that X is "Linked to drugs".

The implication is left unsupported and the victim, the athlete, then feels forced to come out and try to deny the allegation.

Paula tried to prove her innocence. But in the act of protesting her innocence, she unwittingly reinforces in the public consciousness, the connection between drugs and her name. Her denial then becomes more fodder for the press to print the following day, to comment on and to further fuel the speculation that she may have something to hide.

They say her denials do not prove her innocence and so that again implies guilt. This is unfair, unjust and illogical.

Those people who are the victims of such smears should invoke the 'onus of proof principle'.

They should not attempt to prove their innocence; which cannot be done. They should challenge their accusers to put up, or shut up.

They should assert their innocence without any attempt to prove it. They should threaten legal action against anyone who claims or suggests, without evidence, that they have committed wrong doing.

Paula, please don't play the press by their rules. Please don't try to prove your innocence - you are innocent until you have been proven guilty.

It is up to your accusers to prove you guilty; not for you to prove you're not guilty. Paula, please apply the onus of proof principle to your accusers.

Stay strong.

Blogs by Email

Do you want to receive an email whenever we post a new blog? The blogs contain article 5-10 minutes long - ideal for reading during your coffee break!

Your Comments

Further Reading in General Development

  • How to gain more confidence as a new manager
    How to gain more confidence as a manager Are you just starting out in the role of leader or manager? If yes, then you would probably agree that it is sometimes difficult to feel as confident as you would like to feel. You may lack confidence because your situation is new...
    Read Article >
  • How to make more money
    Three steps to making money.
    Read Article >
  • How do you know that what you believe is actually true?
    If something is trending on Twitter, does it make it true? There are various ways in which you gain and verify knowledge, not all of them are reliable. Which ones do you use, and which can you trust?
    Read Article >
  • What Could you Learn from Socrates, Plato and Aristotle?
    What Could You Learn from Socrates, Plato and Aristotle? I am guessing that you have heard the names Socrates, Plato and Aristotle. You probably know that they are the three most famous philosophers in history. But unless you have made it a special study, you may not know much about what...
    Read Article >
  • Ten Top Tips on How to be a Better Manager
    10 Top Tips on How to be a Better Manager If you are a manager, then you have a job that can, sometimes, be difficult to do. There are many aspects to managing tasks and people. And you might need some help with certain aspects of leadership and management. On our...
    Read Article >