Black and White Thinking

Black and White Thinking.

Black and white thinking is a thought-error, which falsely creates a binary choice in situations that are not binary.

For example: You are asked to decide between:

• Black or white.
• A or B.
• With us or against us.
• Right or wrong.
• Truth or lie.
• Innocent or guilty

Black and white thinking is an error because it is an oversimplification.

This type of thinking can be dangerous because, most real-life situations are very complex; they contain many elements. You need to carefully consider many options before you can arrive at a correct decision. The "black and white thinking tool" is often too blunt for that job.

Using "black and white thinking" is like a brain surgeon trying to perform a delicate surgery using a hammer. It never works out well.

Black and white thinking is attractive because it is similar to another concept that is absolutely essential to clear thinking and correct decision making. That concept is called The Law of Identity.

The Law of Identity states that facts are facts, or (A is A).

It is important to understand the difference between:

• black and white thinking, which is wrong, and
• the law of identity, which is right.

"Law of Identity" thinking restates the above list of binary choices to read as follows:

• "A or B" becomes, A or NON-A?
• Right or wrong, becomes, right or NOT right?
• North or south, becomes north or NOT north?
• Guilty or innocent becomes, guilty or NOT guilty.

The Law of Identity looks superficially similar to black and white thinking, but it is important that you spot the difference:

• "You must either be facing NORTH or you are not facing north". Is a correct statement.
• "You must be facing NORTH or facing south". Is not a correct statement - black and white thinking.

You need to check whether the situation you are examining is one where there are multiple possible options and by reducing them to only two, would be an oversimplification.

If you apply a "binary choice" in situations that are NOT binary, then you fall foul of the error of oversimplification (black and white thinking).

Recognise that there are many situations that ARE binary choices.

For example: Launching a rocket is a binary decision. You cannot half-launch a Saturn V space rocket. You either launch it, 100% or not at all.

Equally, you cannot be half pregnant.

These are binary options, because you;

• Are pregnant or not,
• Have launched the Saturn V or not.
• Have passed the exam or not.
• Said it or not.
• Did it or not.

Summary

Black and white thinking falsely creates a binary choice, in situations that are not binary.

• Don't use black and white thinking.
• Do use "law of identity" thinking, (A = A).

Why? Because, facts are facts.

Definition: Black and white thinking

Black and white thinking is a mistake in thought seen in decision making. It offers only two opposite answers, turns rich issues into a yes-or-no, blocks facts that sit between the extremes, and appears when haste or bias pushes out clear analysis. Remove any one of these signs and the label no longer fits.

Article Summary

Black and white thinking squeezes complex life into a false either-or, so use the Law of Identity instead: ask if a claim is or is not, weigh each fact, and your choices grow clearer and fairer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some questions that frequently get asked about this topic during our training sessions.

Thought of something that's not been answered? Ask Us Today!

Did You Know: Key Statistics

About the Author: Chris Farmer

Chris Farmer is the founder of the Corporate Coach Group and has many years' experience in training leaders and managers, in both the public and private sectors, to achieve their organisational goals, especially during tough economic times. He is also well aware of the disciplines and problems associated with running a business.

Over the years, Chris has designed and delivered thousands of training programmes and has coached and motivated many management teams, groups and individuals. His training programmes are both structured and clear, designed to help delegates organise their thinking and, wherever necessary, to improve their techniques and skills.

Blogs by Email

Do you want to receive an email whenever we post a new blog? The blogs contain article 5-10 minutes long - ideal for reading during your coffee break!

Further Reading in Decision Making and Problem Solving

• Creative problem solving and decision making
  Learn a nine-step problem solving method, three thinking tools and paper decision grids to turn feedback into smart decisions. Master clear, creative choices.
  Read Article >
• How To Solve Problems
  Learn a proven 10-step problem solving method that tames fear, gathers facts, sets clear plans and tracks results. Boost critical thinking at work or home.
  Read Article >
• How Rational Thinking is the Key to Success
  Learn how rational thinking and logical reasoning help you align with natural laws, remove contradictions and reach lasting success at work and in life.
  Read Article >
• Key Steps to Better Decisions
  Learn evidence-based steps for better decisions. Gather facts, test ideas, weigh risks, review feedback and adapt to change for ethical, confident decision mak
  Read Article >
• Perception Bias in the Workplace
  Learn what perception bias is, why it harms teams and how to spot and stop it in recruitment. Use written criteria to cut unconscious bias and hire on fact.
  Read Article >

Looking for Leadership and Management Training?

If you're looking to develop your Decision Making and Problem Solving Skills, you may find this Leadership and Management Training Course beneficial:

Open Training Course Pricing and Availability

Next Open Course Starts in 10 days, Birmingham, places available Book Now >